.webp)
.webp)
.webp)
.webp)
Canada faces its largest mortgage renewal wave in history. According to the Bank of Canada, about 60% of all outstanding mortgages are expected to renew in 2025 or 2026. This unprecedented volume creates both challenges and significant opportunities for homeowners who know how to negotiate mortgage renewal in Canada effectively.
The stakes are high. Mortgage holders with five-year fixed-rate contracts renewing in 2025 or 2026 could face average payment increases of 15% to 20% compared with their December 2024 payments. For a household paying $2,000 monthly, that translates to an extra $300 to $400 every month - money that could otherwise go toward savings, investments, or everyday expenses.
With roughly 1.2 million mortgages up for renewal in 2025 alone, lenders are competing for your business. This competition gives you . Simply accepting your lender's first renewal offer leaves money on the table. At Neobanc, we help homeowners maximize their financial position - and you can even earn cashback on mortgage payments to offset increased costs during this renewal period.
This guide walks you through proven negotiation tactics, optimal timing strategies, and how to competition between lenders to secure the best possible rate and terms.
The current renewal crisis stems from mortgages originated during an unusual period. As OSFI reports, 31% of all outstanding mortgages are fixed-rate mortgages and variable-rate fixed-payment mortgages renewing by the end of 2027. These mortgages were originated when rates sat at historic lows before March 2022.
Homeowners who locked in rates below 2% now face renewal rates more than double what they originally secured. Understanding this context helps you negotiate from a position of knowledge rather than panic.
The Bank of Canada cut rates by 225 basis points between mid-2024 and early 2025, holding the overnight rate steady at 2.75% since March 2025. This aggressive cutting cycle has created a more favorable environment for renewals compared to 2024.
Here's where rates currently stand:
According to mortgage industry analysis, the Bank of Canada cut the prime rate four times in 2025 alone. This downward trajectory gives negotiators additional when discussing rates with lenders.
OSFI notes that mortgage maturity concerns have lessened significantly. Renewal rates will likely be lower than those faced in 2024, thanks to seven Bank of Canada rate cuts since June 2024. This improved outlook means lenders are more willing to negotiate competitive terms to retain customers. Your credit score impacts your options, so ensure yours is d before starting negotiations.
Mortgage Rate Trends 2024-2025
| Period | Fixed 5-Year Rate | Variable Rate | Bank of Canada Policy Rate |
|---|---|---|---|
| Q2 2024 | 5.50% | 6.30% | 5.00% |
| Q4 2024 | 4.80% | 5.45% | 3.75% |
| Q1 2025 | 4.40% | 4.95% | 2.75% |
| Q3 2025 | 4.09% | 4.50% | 2.75% |
Start your mortgage renewal process at least four to six months before your renewal date. This timeline allows you to shop around, get pre-approved with other lenders, and create genuine competition for your business. Waiting until your lender sends a renewal notice leaves you with minimal negotiating power.
Most lenders send renewal offers 21 to 30 days before your matyours. By then, you have little time to explore alternatives. Starting early flips the dynamic in your favor.
Lenders are swamped with renewals. With 60% of mortgages renewing in a two-year window, processing times have stretched significantly. Clients report frustration with longer wait times for approvals, document reviews, and rate locks.
Early engagement prevents last-minute scrambles. You need time to:
Using a cashback calculator helps you understand the total value of different offers when comparing options.
Many lenders offer rate holds for 90 to 120 days. Securing a rate hold early protects you if rates increase while giving you flexibility to benefit if rates drop further. Ask every lender about their rate hold policies and whether they offer float-down options that let you take advantage of rate decreases during your hold period.
Before picking up the phone, gather complete information about your existing mortgage. Review your original mortgage agreement for:
Understanding mortgage payment rewards can add value beyond just the interest rate.
Your creditworthiness directly impacts the rates lenders offer. Take steps to your position:
Check your credit report for errors and dispute any inaccuracies. Pay down credit card balances to lower your utilization ratio. Avoid applying for new credit in the months leading up to renewal negotiations. If your credit needs work, our guide on rebuilding credit in Canada provides actionable steps.
Lenders also consider your home's current value and your equity position. If your property has appreciated significantly, you may qualify for better rates. Consider getting a professional appraisal if you believe your home's value has increased substantially since you purchased it.
Look beyond the interest rate. Calculate the total cost of your mortgage including:
Understanding affordability calculations helps you determine what payment increase you can realistically handle.
Mortgage Renewal Cost Comparison
| Factor | Stay with Current Lender | Switch to New Lender | Difference |
|---|---|---|---|
| Appraisal Fee | $0 | $300-$500 | Save $300-$500 |
| Legal/Admin Fees | $0 | $500-$1,000 | Save $500-$1,000 |
| Discharge Fee | $0 | $200-$400 | Save $200-$400 |
| Rate (5-yr fixed) | 4.29%-4.59% | 4.09%-4.29% | Save 0.20%-0.30% |
| Monthly Payment* | $2,450 | $2,380 | Save ~$70/month |
Never negotiate blind. Before contacting your current lender, obtain written quotes from at least three competing lenders. Include:
These quotes become your negotiating ammunition. Your current lender knows you might leave. Make that possibility real by having alternatives in hand.
How you communicate matters. Frame conversations around retention rather than confrontation. Effective phrases include:
"I've been a loyal customer for five years, and I'd like to stay. However, I've received a competitive offer at 4.15% from another lender. Can you match or beat this rate?"
"I understand you want to keep my business. What's the best rate you can offer to make that happen?"
"I'm comparing total value, not just rates. What additional features or benefits can you offer?"
Avoid ultimatums or aggressive tactics. Mortgage specialists have discretion to offer better rates, but they're more likely to use it for polite, prepared customers.
The interest rate gets all the attention, but other terms affect your total cost and flexibility:
For homeowners looking at their credit building journey, consistent mortgage payments contribute positively to your credit history.
Mortgage brokers access wholesale rates from multiple lenders and negotiate on your behalf. They're paid by lenders, not borrowers, in most cases. A good broker can:
Even if you ultimately stay with your current lender, broker quotes provide valuable .
While you negotiate better rates, Neobanc lets you earn 0.5% cashback on your mortgage payments. Every payment works harder for you.
Start EarningThe fixed-versus-variable decision requires understanding current market conditions. According to Owl Mortgage's analysis, fixed-rate mortgages with three to less than five year terms reached 43% of newly extended mortgages at chartered banks in August 2025.
With economists forecasting further rate cuts, variable rates could become increasingly attractive. However, the spread between fixed and variable rates has narrowed significantly.
Variable rates currently sit around 4.1%. If the Bank of Canada continues cutting rates toward the forecasted 2.25%, variable-rate borrowers could see significant savings. However, variable rates carry risks:
OSFI notes higher delinquencies in variable-rate fixed-payment mortgages. If you choose variable, ensure you can handle potential payment increases of 1% to 2% without financial strain.
Fixed rates around 4.3% offer certainty. You know exactly what you'll pay for the entire term. This stability comes at a premium compared to current variable rates, but protects you if rate forecasts prove wrong.
Consider a shorter fixed term - perhaps three years instead of five - if you believe rates will continue falling. This allows you to renew sooner at potentially lower rates while maintaining payment certainty.
Fixed vs Variable Rate Comparison
| Factor | Fixed Rate (4.3%) | Variable Rate (4.1%) | Winner |
|---|---|---|---|
| Monthly Rate | 4.3% | 4.1% | Variable |
| Payment Stability | Guaranteed 5 yrs | Fluctuates w/BoC | Fixed |
| Rate Drop Benefit | None until renew | Immediate savings | Variable |
| Current Popularity | 43% of new loans | ~30% of new loans | Fixed |
| Renewal Risk 2025 | 15-20% increase | Lower increase | Variable |
| Break Penalty | Higher (IRD) | ~3 months interest | Variable |
Bank of Canada analysis indicates about 60% of mortgage holders renewing in 2025 and 2026 will see payment increases. For those with five-year fixed-rate mortgages originated in 2020 or 2021 at rates below 2%, the jump can feel dramatic.
Calculate your expected new payment before negotiations. If your current payment is $2,000 and you're facing a 15% increase, budget for $2,300 monthly. Knowing this number helps you negotiate from reality rather than hope.
Several strategies can help manage increased mortgage costs:
Managing your overall household bills efficiently frees up budget room for higher mortgage payments.
In some cases, breaking your current mortgage before renewal makes financial sense. If rates have dropped significantly and you have years remaining on your term, the interest savings might exceed the penalty costs.
Request a penalty quote from your lender. Compare this against potential savings from refinancing at today's lower rates. Factor in any legal and appraisal fees for a complete picture.
OSFI highlights higher delinquencies in business-for-self mortgage portfolios. If you're self-employed, expect more scrutiny at renewal. Prepare:
Start gathering these documents early. Some lenders specialize in self-employed borrowers and may offer better terms than traditional banks.
Investment property mortgages face additional challenges. OSFI notes higher delinquencies in investor mortgage portfolios. Lenders may require:
Landlords should document rental income carefully and maintain strong personal credit to secure competitive renewal terms.
If this is your first mortgage renewal, the process might feel overwhelming. Remember that you have more power than you think. Lenders don't want to lose customers - acquiring new borrowers costs them money.
Don't assume your current lender will automatically offer the best rate. In many cases, lenders reserve their most competitive rates for new customers. You may need to threaten leaving to access retention rates comparable to what new borrowers receive.
For those still building their financial foundation, resources on first credit cards and credit building strategies support your overall financial health.
Understanding where the housing market is headed helps contextualize your renewal decision. According to CREA forecasts cited in year-end reviews, national home sales were expected to decline by approximately 3.5% in 2025 to around 467,100 units.
However, 2026 looks brighter. CREA projects national home sales to rebound by up to 4.5%, with average home prices rising modestly - around 3.3% increase projected.
Total residential mortgage debt in Canada reached approximately $2.3 trillion by August 2025, up 4.8% from a year earlier. The national household debt-to-income ratio remained at 181.8% in Q2 2025. For every dollar of disposable income Canadian households had, there was about $1.82 of debt.
This context matters for your negotiation. Lenders are increasingly cautious, but they also need quality borrowers. If your financial position is strong, emphasize this in negotiations.
Mortgage delinquency rates vary significantly by region. Ontario saw an alarming year-over-year jump of 44% in mortgage delinquency rates, rising to 0.23% in Q2 2025, with Toronto at 0.24%.
If you're in a higher-delinquency region, lenders may be more cautious. Conversely, if your payment history is perfect in a troubled market, that strengthens your negotiating position.
Understanding regional dynamics like credit requirements in Ontario provides useful context for your overall financial planning.
Working with real estate professionals can provide additional market insights if you're considering selling or refinancing.
Your lender's initial renewal offer is rarely their best rate. Banks build negotiating room into their posted rates. A simple phone call can often reduce your rate by 0.25% to 0.50% - potentially saving thousands over your term.
A mortgage with a slightly higher rate but better prepayment privileges might cost you less if you plan to make lump-sum payments. Evaluate the complete package, not just the headline number.
Procrastination limits your options. With lenders overwhelmed by renewal volume, last-minute applications face delays and reduced negotiating power.
Your credit score directly impacts available rates. Reviewing resources on how payments affect credit helps you understand and your position.
Verbal promises mean nothing. Ensure all agreed terms appear in your written mortgage commitment before signing.
Some Canadians overlook opportunities to earn value on mortgage payments. At Neobanc, we help homeowners earn cashback on mortgage payments, turning a necessary expense into a rewarding one. Over a five-year term, these rewards add up significantly.
Your mortgage renewal is one piece of your financial picture. Consider how your decision fits with broader goals:
Resources like our financial articles library provide guidance on comprehensive financial planning.
While managing your mortgage, explore other ways to strengthen your financial position. Options like guaranteed approval credit cards or easy approval options can help diversify your credit profile.
For those with credit challenges, specialized credit cards or no credit check alternatives provide pathways to improvement.
Negotiating your mortgage renewal in Canada doesn't require special skills - just preparation, research, and willingness to ask for better terms. With roughly 60% of mortgages renewing in 2025 and 2026, you're not alone in facing this challenge. But you can be among those who turn it into an opportunity.
Start early. Gather competitive quotes. Know your numbers. And remember that your current lender wants to keep your business - use that to secure the best possible rate and terms.
The difference between accepting a first offer and negotiating effectively can mean thousands of dollars in savings over your mortgage term. That's money better spent on your family, your future, or simply your peace of mind.
Visit our FAQ section for answers to common questions, or explore how Neobanc helps Canadians make their essential payments more rewarding. For enterprise solutions, we offer programs designed for larger organizations managing multiple properties.
With Neobanc, you can earn 0.5% cashback on your mortgage payments. Make your renewed mortgage work even harder for you.
Start Earning CashbackStart negotiating your mortgage renewal at least four to six months before your renewal date. This timeline allows you to shop around, get pre-approved with other lenders, and create genuine competition for your business. Most lenders send renewal offers only 21 to 30 days before maturity, leaving minimal time to explore alternatives. With 60% of Canadian mortgages renewing in 2025-2026, processing times have stretched significantly, making early engagement essential to avoid last-minute scrambles.
Yes, you can absolutely negotiate your mortgage renewal rate with your current lender, and you should. Lenders are competing for business during this historic renewal wave, giving you significant leverage. Before contacting your current lender, obtain written quotes from at least three competing lenders including major banks, credit unions, and mortgage brokers. Present these competitive offers and ask your lender to match or beat them. Mortgage specialists have discretion to offer better rates, especially for prepared customers with alternatives in hand.
If you don't renew your mortgage before the term ends, your lender will typically convert your mortgage to an open mortgage at a higher interest rate or roll it into a short-term variable rate product. This default option almost always costs more than actively negotiating a renewal. You lose leverage and may face unfavorable terms. To avoid this situation, start the renewal process four to six months early and secure a rate hold, which many lenders offer for 90 to 120 days.
The choice between fixed and variable rates at renewal in 2025 depends on your risk tolerance and market outlook. Fixed rates currently hover around 4.09% for insured mortgages, while variable rates sit around 4.1%. With the Bank of Canada expected to drop the policy rate to 2.25% by year-end 2025, variable rates could decrease further. However, fixed rates offer payment certainty. Most economists see continued rate cuts ahead, which may favor variable rate borrowers willing to accept some uncertainty.
Mortgage payments at renewal could increase significantly for homeowners who locked in historic low rates before March 2022. According to the Bank of Canada, homeowners with five-year fixed-rate contracts renewing in 2025 or 2026 could face average payment increases of 15% to 20% compared with December 2024 payments. For a household paying $2,000 monthly, that translates to an extra $300 to $400 every month. However, recent rate cuts have improved the outlook compared to 2024 renewals.
Switching lenders at mortgage renewal can be worthwhile if the savings outweigh the costs. You may access better rates, especially from monoline lenders or credit unions. However, switching involves potential costs including legal fees, appraisals, and discharge fees. Calculate the total cost difference over your new term, not just the rate difference. If switching saves you thousands in interest over five years and the fees are a few hundred dollars, it makes financial sense. Many lenders also offer cashback to offset switching costs.
For the best mortgage renewal rates, aim for a credit score of at least 680, though scores above 720 typically qualify for the most competitive offers. Your creditworthiness directly impacts the rates lenders offer. Before negotiating, check your credit report for errors, pay down credit card balances to lower your utilization ratio, and avoid applying for new credit in the months leading up to renewal. If your credit needs improvement, addressing issues early gives you time to strengthen your position.
.svg){kind=small}
